Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Phillips's avatar

Excellent as always.

I was trained at a time when the therapy for infarction was morphine, oxygen nitroglycerin, aspirin, and prayer. As one of two fellows in a 1000 bed military USAF hospital, I put in countless SG catheters to optimize the wedge pressure! Seemed like a good idea at the time.

We've come a long way certainly.

Fast-forward 40 some years and I rode in the ambulance with my neighbor to our heart hospital. He called me at 10 o'clock having chest pain. We arrived at the heart hospital 10:49 PM and he was stented at 11 pm. (I called ahead) . He had a normal ejection fraction fracture post MI.

That sounds like a lot of progress except when I went to target yesterday to look for some battery operated Christmas lights and I realized just looking around I'm not sure you need CRP testing to see who is at risk.

I guess on a personal level if you're interested in your health and your neighbor happens to be a cardiologist you can find and stabilize, vulnerable plaque and prevent infarction.

On the flipside what has changed is that if I blindfolded you and dropped you into a strip mall ; unless you could look at a local trees you would have no idea where you were in the United States. You would see McDonald's, a cheesecake, factory, dine in movie theater with buttered popcorn and 80 ounce sugar filled sodas being served to sedentary people.

I worked with a group of cardiologists and we opened up a partial meal replacement Diet program The patients bought plant protein meals to replace two meals a day. They actually saved money since they weren't eating out. We took off close to 18,000 pounds but dieting is not easy. These were very vocal and aggressive cardiologists but the best we could do is get 7% of the patients even to consider the diet!

When we talked to the insurance companies about supporting the program, even with a nominal $25 a week contribution- they said they were not in the long-term health business.

They said they were in the money management business. The average patient changed insurance companies every 18 months so why should prevention be on their dime. This was a true conversation.

Medicare is not a great payer for prevention as well.

The GLP's if they can be provided, may turn out to be the penicillin of our generation.

Removing processed sugar from the food chain, and certainly from the consumer, I think will save more lives than any other intervention.

But what do I know I put those stupid swans in and still gave Lasix and fluids!

Thank you again. I really enjoy the writing.

Susan Scheid's avatar

A great deal of this sailed over my head, but nonetheless, there is always knowledge to be gained from your essays. In this one:

First, you state: “Unlike stable plaque, the vulnerable plaque does not contain dense calcification. (This one of the reasons I have never ordered a CT calcium score for any patient since they are often highly misleading).” Do you mean by this that vulnerable plaque does not show up on a CT calcium score?

Second, and even more important, was your observation “We have far better ways to identify vulnerable patients and we’re not doing it” and you noted the PRS score. It came to my attention recently that, for older patients, using the LDL as a proxy for propensity to heart disease is problematic, at least for those who have no prior history of CVS. It sounds like the PRS score could be important for overcoming that deficiency in assessment.

Last, and related, I would welcome your view on the relative merits of the MESA, PREVENT, and PCE calculators as predictive of propensity to CVS.

Thank you, as always, for bringing us the news.

18 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?